Authenticating a 1962 Dakota Red Fender Jazzmaster
First and foremost, it is essential to understand that when you buy a vintage guitar you are both trading and investing. You are an active participant in a live, evolving market, complete with the flows, peaks, troughs, and fractal self-similarities found within the financial stock market. When bought correctly, vintage guitars can be exceptionally profitable investments. Traded intelligently in line with the market, whether for short- or long-term gain, a vintage guitar can often appreciate substantially when compared with many other collectible assets.
Here is the single greatest piece of advice I could possibly offer to anyone taking the leap into the vintage guitar market as a trader or investor: never listen blindly to dealers. More importantly, if you feel you must rely on dealers to tell you what to buy, you are not yet ready to enter the market. That may be an unpopular view, particularly from someone who actively invests and trades within this space, but it is the most valuable guidance I can give. The reality is that dealer descriptions often follow a familiar formula: every vintage guitar is “beautiful”, “the one”, “all original”, “a must-have”, “a great investment”, “awesome”, “will be sold immediately”, “plays like butter” (my personal favourite) and supposedly destined to be worth several times more in ten years. You can almost predict the write-up before reading it. If these dealers genuinely believed every word they typed, they would take their own advice and invest accordingly. They rarely do. The ones who do, however, are the vintage guitar dealers genuinely worth knowing.
If you are going to invest in a market using money you have worked hard to earn, or if you are putting existing capital to work, the decision must ultimately be yours. Your investment, and its long- or short-term outcome, should never be determined by outside influence, particularly from a dealer whose aim is to profit from the sale. That includes me. To make sound decisions, and this may sound almost preposterous, you must be able to think independently and respond to what the market is telling you. The second and final strategic point I would offer is this: have two investment strategies when entering the vintage guitar market. Most people have only one, which is simply to buy low and sell high. Naturally, that can be effective, but it is not always optimal. Have you ever wondered why the same vintage guitars remain with the same dealer for years, or why they are passed from dealer to dealer without finding an investor? This is precisely why. You, as an investor, must also trade with the market. You need to optimise a mixed strategy and allow that strategy to determine how you invest.
To invest successfully, you need a bona fide understanding of both the vintage guitar market and your own investment strategies. Put simply, you need to know exactly what you are investing in as a profitable commodity: a vintage guitar.
In this article, we are positioning ourselves within the highly desirable market segment of rare custom-colour Fender guitars from the golden era of the early 1960s, specifically 1962. As an investor, you need to buy with confidence and fully understand the authentication process. The stages I share below should prove invaluable.
Stage 1: Observation
When I am presented with a vintage guitar for the first time, I place the cased instrument on my desk, open the case, and simply take it in. There is no need to remove the guitar immediately. Spend time carefully observing both the guitar and its so-called original case. Look carefully and smell carefully; both senses matter. You cannot convincingly fake the smell of a vintage guitar. Original guitars and their original cases naturally develop a shared character over time. If you cannot detect that connection, there may be a reason. This 1962 Dakota Red Fender Jazzmaster has not spent its entire life in the period-correct brown Tolex case. I know this not only because the smell of the guitar and case does not quite match, but because I bought the case myself from a friend. Dealers may not tell you this, but I will. This particular Jazzmaster has spent its entire life in the UK, and if you know anything about UK distribution in the 1960s, you will know that many Fender guitars were sold without their USA-made cases. They were often supplied with no case at all, or with a UK distributor case, such as a Jennings or Selmer. A similar situation occurred in Italy. This particular guitar was sold without a case. The original owner handmade his own case, and it is included in the sale if you want it, but you have been warned: it is not worth the additional shipping charge.
Here is something many people do not realise about Fender Jazzmaster and Jaguar cases: they are not the same. Jaguar cases have a small wooden support near the headstock, whereas Jazzmaster cases do not. This compensates for the Jaguar’s slightly shorter overall length. A case comparison is shown below.
Now consider the guitar in question. Examine whether anything stands out as unusual, inconsistent, or incorrect for the period. In 1962, a Dakota Red Fender Jazzmaster, being a pastel colour, would not have had a clear coat applied over the Duco Dakota Red paint, and that is the case here. This changed around mid-1963, when all pastel colours were given a clear coat, often altering their original finish shade over time. Look for any touch-up work, which can be difficult to spot when professionally applied; for this reason, a UV blacklight can be extremely useful.
Now turn to the hardware and plastics. Ask yourself whether the patina is consistent throughout. Do the control knobs show matching yet subtle crazing? Does the ageing of the tuning pegs correspond naturally with the neck? Take your time and observe carefully, calmly, and without forcing conclusions. For 1962, you should expect to see single-line Kluson Deluxe tuners, with the word “Deluxe” most prominent on the chrome tuner cover.
Now for one of the most common mistakes I see when dealers and sellers describe vintage Jaguars or Jazzmasters: the bridge. In 1962, you should expect to see what I refer to as the staggered-saddle, first-variant offset bridge. Not many people realise this, but Fender Jaguar and Jazzmaster bridges were not identical throughout the 1958–1975 period. There are three principal variations of the offset Jaguar/Jazzmaster bridge. The earliest design, the staggered-saddle Jaguar/Jazzmaster bridge, featured staggered saddle grooves to compensate for the varying string gauges across the guitar. It was an excellent idea, though somewhat limiting in practice. This bridge design can be found from 1958 to early 1963. At some point in 1963, Fender abandoned the staggered-saddle design and moved to a consistent groove pattern across the strings. This became the typical Jazzmaster/Jaguar bridge of the 1960s and remained in use until early 1969. In 1969, the bridge changed again, this time to a different base with flatter “nipples” above the posts, while the saddles themselves remained the same as the second variant.
Now let’s turn our attention to my favourite part of the authentication process: the celluloid nitrate pickguard. For this period, its shade of “white” depends on a fascinating combination of factors, including humidity, smoke exposure, UV exposure, and the degree of natural bleeding from the middle black layer into the upper white layer. Look very carefully and you can see this metamorphosis gradually unfolding. The results vary considerably, but original guards can range from slightly green or almost white, to cream-white, to a greyish hue, or to a distinct and consistent green. This particular pickguard sits, in my view, within the typical mid-range green-grey spectrum, with areas of ingrained dirt and playwear around the controls.
An important observation is the angle at which the guard is cut against the body, as well as the character of the cut itself. Once you have handled enough period-correct guards, you begin to recognise the correct angle and the subtle way the cut fans out differently from year to year. In 1962, the cut is relatively consistent, whereas by 1964 it begins to flatten into a shallower profile. Again, this is where an experienced eye and genuine hands-on expertise are essential. Look for the easy-to-spot chatter lines running vertically down the cut of the guard, and expect to see waves, irregularities, and small imperfections in the overall cut.
Finally, all original Fender Jazzmaster guards will usually show some degree of shrinkage and warping, owing to the number of screws used and the sheer size of the guard.
Consider the headstock decals. Expect to find some shrinkage, and look for a ghost shadow indicating where the decals were originally positioned. This shift can be extremely subtle or quite obvious, depending on what the guitar has been exposed to over time.
As far as observation goes, before moving into the technicalities, this is about as far as you can reasonably take it. If you are not satisfied at this stage, especially when buying online, it is time to smile politely and walk away.
Stage 2: Finish Analysis
This is arguably the most important factor when it comes to your investment: the originality and condition of the finish. It is worth noting that a rare custom-colour, pre-CBS Fender Jazzmaster can be investment-worthy in almost any condition. That is precisely why average or poor-condition Foam Green or Sonic Blue Fender Jazzmasters rarely appear on the open market.
As noted earlier, a 1962 Dakota Red finish should not have a clear coat applied over it. This is usually straightforward to identify. Dakota Red, like other pastel colours from this period, is commonly prone to flaking precisely because it lacks that protective clear-coat layer. The correct base coat for this period is Desert Sand, which was also a common foundation for many custom colours in 1962.
Now consider common factory markings, especially within the cavities, screw holes, and nail holes. Note the positions where you would expect to find screw holes in 1962, as shown. The nail and screw holes should be free from paint,
although traces of paint can often be seen within the screw threads and may correspond subtly with the surrounding finish.
Feel the density of the wood and the applied paint, and even smell the finish. The paint should feel rock solid and fully cured, as though all moisture has long since left it; this is difficult to describe in words, but unmistakable once you have experienced it.
Look closely at how the paint and parts mate together. Check whether oxidation on the underside of the pickguard is also reflected on the body. Make sure the neck mates correctly with the body, and look for any outliers that do not correspond between the neck and the body. Take your time here; everything should make sense without lingering doubt. If there are no doubts at this point in the finish-analysis stage, you are most likely holding a vintage guitar genuinely worth buying. Finally, although not directly related to the finish, check for body dowel holes, usually found on the lower part of the body and around the back right shoulder area. This does not confirm the originality of the finish, but it is a useful indication that the body has been constructed correctly for the period. Bear in mind that these dowel markings can also be visible on a refinished guitar.
Stage 3: Period-Correct Parts
Soldering: one very important observation is the originality of the solder joints. This is often overlooked by overconfident dealers focused primarily on maximising profit. If all solder joints are original and untampered with, that is a real bonus. However, keep in mind that if a solder joint appears to have received some attention, it may simply have been necessary. These joints are more than 60 years old and could easily have developed weak connections requiring careful reheating. Do not let that alone put you off. This Dakota Red Fender Jazzmaster retains fully original solder joints, with no evidence of tampering or repair.
Plastics: unless you are the original owner, you can never know with absolute certainty whether any plastic component has been replaced or not. The best approach is to look for consistent patina. On this Jazzmaster, the volume and tone knobs are period-correct and show matching ageing.
Pickup covers are particularly interesting. They are made from a different material to the pickguard and, because of their size, often contrast noticeably with a greened guard. The pickup covers generally remain white if the guitar has been kept clean, although they can stain and develop tan lines beneath the strings or where a hand may rest. Again, you can never be absolutely certain that they have not been changed, although replacement is relatively uncommon. Look for the factory circular marking beneath the cover, and expect to see screw marks where pickup heights have been adjusted over the years. The switch tips tell a similar story.
Electronics: internally, one of the most important checks is to ensure that the harness, pickups, and masking tape remain in place. You do not want to see obvious alterations, snapped tape, or missing tape. Shown above is an all-original example of a 1962 harness.
Neck profile:
I am going to be direct: Fender necks are frequently replaced and later paired with different bodies. This may be less common with offset Fender guitars than with Stratocasters, but it remains an important consideration. For the purposes of this article, expect a late-1962 example to have a full-feeling yet tapered neck profile, complete with a Brazilian rosewood fretboard. A CITES Article 10 Certificate is required to offer such an instrument for sale or to present it to the general public. Unfortunately, the natural history of these vintage guitars is too often overlooked, and many are sold without the appropriate certification. It is also highly reassuring to see the original frets and nut, as is the case with this 1962 Dakota Red Fender Jazzmaster. Keep in mind, however, that there is nothing inherently wrong with an exact-specification refret and a new bone nut. If such work has been carried out, it was most likely done because the instrument had become difficult or impossible to play. Provided the work has been executed expertly, with no chips or damage to the fretboard, do not let it discourage you from investing.
Enjoy the waves!
Comments